Mystery shopper tool kit

Top tips for mystery shoppers

How to be one of our top rated Silent Customers. We favour Silent Customers whose reports need the fewest edits, because that helps us give the best service to our clients and return approved reports to them quickly.

How grading works

Every report is graded

You can view your average grading on your home page. After we’ve reviewed your report, we’ll email you the grading for that report with some brief written feedback. We can’t give you details of every single edit we make, as it would take too long, but we try to highlight specific ways to improve your next report as well as things you did well.

The grading system helps us choose the most proficient Silent Customers for future visits. If our editors mark you down, it’s not because they are mean or harsh: it just reflects the time and effort they’ve spent on corrections and changes.

The scoring

10 categories, each marked 3 to 0

An average score of 90% is classed as good, although we love to get accurate and comprehensive reports so we can give you full marks.

The 10 grading categories

What our editors look for

01

Fulfilling the brief

How accurately you read and follow instructions

Please read all the information on your Summary Info, Briefing Sheet and the questions carefully before you go, so that you don’t forget to check something, forget to order something, or go to the wrong venue or at the wrong time of day.

02

Spelling and grammar

Including punctuation and capital letters

Most Silent Customers miss points on this grading. Please check for typos and misspellings before you submit your review. Use punctuation, so that when you read it back to yourself, your writing makes sense. Write in complete sentences, with capitals at the beginning and full stops at the end.

03

Qualifying observations

Supporting your YES or NO answers with evidence in the comments

We need you to give reasons for your YES or NO answers, especially if you have marked them down for something. Use the comment boxes to explain what happened, so we and the client can see that your mark is fair.

Example

Question: Were you offered coffee? Answer: No

Poor comment

“I was not offered coffee.” This does not tell us whether you asked for it before they had the chance to offer it, whether they had no coffee available, or whether they just forgot. If you asked before they had the chance to offer, it would be unfair to mark them down.

Good comment

“No-one offered coffee when they took the dessert order. After our dessert plates were cleared, I waited to see if they would offer but the waitress went away. I then went to the bar to ask for coffees.”

04

Reasonable suggestions

Answering as a genuine customer, in the context of the style of venue

Making drastic changes isn’t within the power of managers and tenants. Suggesting structural changes to buildings or other costly alterations is unrealistic.

Don’t write that something is against statutory or legal regulations. You’re there as an ordinary customer. Even if you have the professional qualifications to make such comments, you can’t produce your credentials, because Silent Customers are anonymous. Comment on what you see and experience as if you were a genuine diner or drinker.

Please don’t mark down on the basis of a personal, subjective opinion.

Example

Question: Were the staff appropriately dressed? Answer: No

Poor comment

“They looked scruffy!” Your opinion of what is scruffy might be different from mine. You need to describe what you saw.

Good comment

“The waiter was wearing ripped jeans and a dirty light blue T-shirt.” Your editor will agree that this isn’t appropriate dress. If you had said the waiter wasn’t wearing a tie with his suit, that’s a different definition of scruffy, and with that information we could decide whether your answer of ‘No’ was fair.

05

Kind and motivational

We encourage positive change through motivation, so all feedback must be constructive and non-judgemental

It’s hard to take a positive tone when you’ve had a bad experience of service or food. But that’s what we have to do. You have been invited, at the client’s expense, to review their business. They welcome honest feedback and don’t expect every visit to be perfect, but they do reasonably expect you to explain what happened objectively and without vitriol or sarcasm.

Keep in mind that not only the management team but the staff themselves will read the report. We believe nobody who runs a pub or restaurant goes to work to do a bad job or disappoint customers. They’re working hard in an often tough and pressured job and believe they’re doing their best.

Be honest and sincere, but think about how you’d deliver the feedback to the manager or owner face to face. If you wouldn’t say it that way, don’t write it that way. If you mark down, explain neutrally what happened and make a positive statement about what could have been a better way to do it.

Good comment

“I would have liked the waiter to make eye contact and greet me immediately.”

Poor comment

“I was disappointed that the waiter ignored me when I arrived.”

“Could” is often easier to accept than “should” in feedback, and makes statements feel less judgemental.

Good comment

“The waiter could have cleared the table more quickly.”

Poor comment

“The waiter should have cleared the table more quickly.”

Silent Customers are motivators, not critics, and our wording needs to show that. If something is wrong, you don’t need to repeat it, use harsh words or let it colour the rest of your review. You don’t need to say you were ‘disappointed’ when you describe a fault; it feels too disapproving. We are there to observe and report.

06

Quantitative narrative

The amount of commentary you write

Just because it says ‘min 150 characters’ does not mean that’s all you need to say. We want you to describe your experience clearly. Write as much as you need to explain what happened, or what you’d like to have happened.

There’s no need to pad it out with repetition or unsupported personal opinion. Don’t just retype the question to make up the words.

Do not be tempted to use AI to pad it out either. These programmes are not yet sophisticated enough to interpret the human experience in context, and the result is usually exaggerated, fantastical feedback which invalidates the real human experience and therefore the entire survey.

07

Objective, relevant writing style

Commentary that is fluent and natural, without AI embellishment

Use a variety of language to describe your experiences and make your feedback objective and interesting to read. A good tip is to read out loud what you’ve written: it should sound fluent, natural and genuine.

Using basic adjectives such as ‘nice’ and ‘tasty’ in every sentence comes across as unsophisticated and lazy. Without an explanation of why you used them, these adjectives add nothing, since ‘nice’ to one person could mean ‘average’ to another or ‘delicious’ to someone else.

Using AI programmes to embellish or interpret your narrative usually results in overly effusive, often flowery descriptions of something very ordinary, such as a basic burger or a routine service interaction. This bears no relation to the real experience, is seen as fantastical by the reader and invalidates the entire survey. When you read it back, ask yourself: does this reflect my actual experience? Does it describe what I really felt, tasted and experienced? If not, rewrite it in your own words.

Our editors will ask you to rewrite your report and will mark you down if your feedback is overly effusive. We do not need AI detectors to make this assessment.

08

Photos, images and accurate times and dates

Check the formats and quality

Check that dates, times and amounts are accurate and images are good quality, and the right way up, before you submit your report.

Make sure you know what photos you need to take before you go on the visit, and that your phone is charged. Email them to yourself to avoid losing them.

Do not take pictures of children, or anywhere near children if you are alone with them. Avoid including people in your photos where possible, and do not take pictures in which people’s faces or identities can be recognised.

Phone cameras time-stamp every picture. Please be honest about the time you arrived at the venue, as we can see when the pictures were taken.

If you forget to take a photo, do not be tempted to upload one from a website. If we do not pick up on it, the client may, and that invalidates the integrity of your entire survey.

09

Answers correlate with comments

Consistent answers throughout

All answers need to correlate with comments in every other part of the survey. If you answer all the questions about housekeeping positively with YES, then later say in the overall impressions section that you would have liked the venue to be cleaner, that’s contradictory.

Check your answers are consistent and support your summaries at the end of the survey.

10

Timely submission of survey (24 hours)

Let us know in good time if there’s a problem

You need to submit your survey within 24 hours of your actual visit. Please let us know if your report is going to be later than this, before we need to chase you.

Once you have submitted it, please keep an eye on your inbox in case we have sent it back with queries. We will need you to make the requested edits and resubmit it the same day, so that we have time to check it again before we send it to our client.

Not registered yet?

Register your profile and we will let you know when visits are available in your area.

Explore more

Everything you need before your next visit.

Reputation Management

Mystery Visits

Phone & Online Audits

Free Training Tools

Free Training Tools

Intercepting Complaints

Check-backs and complaint handling go hand in hand. Intercepting a problem before a customer tells you, or Google, not only prevents negative word-of-mouth but can increase revenue through loyalty and positive PR.

Use our fun PEP talk sheets to support your front-line teams in learning how to avoid complaints.

Engaging Conversations

Building a natural and genuine rapport with guests can be the most positive and memorable part of their dining experience. Whilst the food and the environment can be remarkable by itself, making a customer feel that they are more than just a table number, has a far wider reach in terms of spreading positive word-of-mouth.

Use our fun PEP talk sheet to support your front-line teams in learning how to have engaging conversations.

Positive Body Language

Being able to communicate positivity, and with enthusiasm, encourages customers to reciprocate in the same manner. However, most of us are unaware of how we are perceived by others and, whilst we may think we are coming across as welcoming and friendly, our body language could be telling a different story.

Use our fun PEP talk sheet to support your front-line teams in understand the importance of self-awareness.

Relevant Recommendations

Team members need good product knowledge to be able to describe and enthuse, but often don’t know what many of the dishes taste like. A lack of upselling is also often due to a lack of confidence in knowing where to start a conversation that leads to a recommendation.

Use our fun PEP talk sheet to support your front-line teams in learning how to upsell.