How Does Mystery Shopping Work?

In short mystery shopping works by delivering feedback to the front lines, covering all learning styles and motivating change.

Well, it does when it’s delivered by Silent Customer because it’s our values that underpin the success of our mystery shopping services.    

 

How does mystery shopping work

 

As a child, my mother always told me I had the ‘attention span of a gnat’. My maths teachers said I ‘just needed to apply myself ‘ and my grandfather threatened me with the ‘Wrath of God’ because I couldn’t learn my times tables.  My English teachers couldn’t understand why I could apply myself to literature but not literacy. I couldn’t catch or throw and was always last at running and last to be picked for teams at school.

It took several driving instructors to find the one with the patience to teach me to drive and I will never forget my group skiing instructor throwing his hands in the air in exasperation and exclaiming ‘I just don’t know why you can’t get it Janet!’ I was in my 30s and it reduced me to tears, just like all the other times people expressed their disappointment and frustrations with my apparent ‘refusal’ to learn. 

I guess, these days I would be diagnosed as having ADHD, dyslexia, dyspraxia, and dyscalculia.  The only actual thing I was diagnosed for, when I was 40, was a hole in my heart… I guess that explains the inability to run efficiently at least. 

What’s my point? Well, nobody goes out to be terrible at stuff. It makes you excluded, marginalised and written off. Nobody goes out to not fit in. If you tell someone, they need to try harder…. don’t you think they would if they could? Usually, it’s not a conscious choice.   

 

How does mystery shopping work

 

For me, it meant I went overboard to please people by serving them what I had left available to me. I was a grafter, hardworking, capable, efficient and I was creative and perceptive of people. I found my calling in hospitality.   

I can’t ‘do maths’ but I can balance a profit and loss sheet.  I can’t read or write with accuracy, but I can convey sentiment.

I don’t force ‘potential’ in people.  I see their talents and help them and their colleagues to accept their ‘can’t dos’ and cheerlead their ‘can dos’.  My mantra has always been if your employees can’t do something you need them to do, then you shouldn’t have employed them. The fault is with you, not the employee. Redress your recruitment processes, it will make it less painful for everyone.   

Do I think labelling people as ‘neurodiverse’ is unhelpful? Yes. I do. Do I think our current education system is archaic and exclusive only for those with one learning style. Yes. I do.  I think we should stop giving people labels to enable the ‘poor me’ disability excuse and just embrace that we are all different and have something to offer. 

 

I started Silent Customer for two reasons. 

  1. I simply couldn’t work for cruel managers anymore. Don’t get me wrong. I had some amazing managers without whom I wouldn’t have conquered my fear of maths, but equally, I had some terrible ones whose overly critical and chastising management styles all but destroyed me.    
  2. As a restaurant manager myself I realised there is a better way to treat the people you work with. Words of encouragement and giving feedback in a way that was palatable, fair and kind was a better way to drive business. These values are the veins of our business and run through every mystery shopping report that is delivered to our clients’ teams.

 

We can help you understand how mystery shopping can work for your business.  If you care about your teams and want them to be the driving force of your business, then get in touch. 

Share:

Twitter
LinkedIn
Facebook

Related Posts

Have training apps had their day?

Have training apps had their day? I think they probably have. We’re ‘apped out’. Of course, apps still have an important place for things like health & safety, risk assessments, food safety regulations and HR compliance. But beyond that, if you want your team to genuinely go above and beyond when looking after customers, especially in customer-facing roles, then the training needs to be human too. When I started Silent Customer back in 2008, the

Read More »

BYO – so, there’s a thought…

BYO – so there’s a thought… Conversations about an unlicensed local sushi bar encouraging customers to bring their own wine sparked debate about whether this should make a comeback. With costs spiraling and eating out becoming more of an occasional treat than a regular pastime with friends – and with more people staying at home – could corkage on BYO help make going out feel more affordable again? Would offering BYO give customers the impression

Read More »

Order-at-the-table-apps should generate more engagement, not less.

Order-at-the-table-apps should generate more engagement, not less. Tim Martin wrote an article about how apps are reducing customer engagement. But I actually see them as a fantastic opportunity to do the absolute opposite. I’m sorry, but how is having a stressed or disengaged server pressing buttons on a handheld device at your table any better than you inputting your own order into an app? No – apps are a great opportunity to save money on

Read More »

Do GMs have a parental role?

Do GM’s have a parental role? In a word – Yes. Adults are really just grown-up children. We might not throw ourselves on the floor anymore, but we still have our versions of tantrums. Most of us keep them inside; a few make their displeasure known. Either way, angst and tears rarely help anyone. Remember Super Nanny? The meltdowns were almost always for the same reasons: 📍Parents hadn’t set clear expectations 📍They hadn’t modelled the

Read More »

Q: Why are my Google reviews disappearing?

A: In 2025 and 2026, Google has dramatically increased its moderation of business reviews. It appears this has ramped up in late January 2026. This means that many reviews – both positive and negative – are being removed from business profiles across all industries. This is a widespread issue affecting businesses globally, including restaurants, automotive, home services, retails and insurance agencies. The main reasons for these removals include: Automated moderation by Google’s systems, which uses artificial

Read More »

What is complex feedback and why do I need it?

Machine Learning v Human Learning. Machine Learning (AI as it has been branded) has been around for 20 years. It just didn’t have the funding or commercial focus to make money until recently. Currently, it tells us stuff that we tell it. It needs information and instruction to give an output, which mostly comes from us humans. The AI the majority of us have access to doesn’t learn further than how it has been programmed.

Read More »

Reputation Management

Mystery Visits

Phone & Online Audits

Free Training Tools

Free Training Tools

Intercepting Complaints

Check-backs and complaint handling go hand in hand. Intercepting a problem before a customer tells you, or Google, not only prevents negative word-of-mouth but can increase revenue through loyalty and positive PR.

Use our fun PEP talk sheets to support your front-line teams in learning how to avoid complaints.

Engaging Conversations

Building a natural and genuine rapport with guests can be the most positive and memorable part of their dining experience. Whilst the food and the environment can be remarkable by itself, making a customer feel that they are more than just a table number, has a far wider reach in terms of spreading positive word-of-mouth.

Use our fun PEP talk sheet to support your front-line teams in learning how to have engaging conversations.

Positive Body Language

Being able to communicate positivity, and with enthusiasm, encourages customers to reciprocate in the same manner. However, most of us are unaware of how we are perceived by others and, whilst we may think we are coming across as welcoming and friendly, our body language could be telling a different story.

Use our fun PEP talk sheet to support your front-line teams in understand the importance of self-awareness.

Relevant Recommendations

Team members need good product knowledge to be able to describe and enthuse, but often don’t know what many of the dishes taste like. A lack of upselling is also often due to a lack of confidence in knowing where to start a conversation that leads to a recommendation.

Use our fun PEP talk sheet to support your front-line teams in learning how to upsell.